more thrilling now
than it ever was
The Contestant is a documentary about a 1998 Japanese reality show starring Nasubi(real name Tomoaki Hamatsu) who was confined to a studio apartment and lived off magazine giveaways for 15 months.
Through contemporary interviews, footage from the show, and archival news clips Nasubi's story is told. Its interesting and bizarre and certainly a telling precursor to the cavalcade of reality TV to come. But it plays more like a summary of the show and neither Nasubi himself or the shows creator/producer Toshio Tsuchiya are able to offer much in the way of insight about the experience other than it was traumatic. No one is really held responsible, there is no comment about Japanese culture(or humanity at large), no analysis about reality TV as a genre, most of the questions the story itself raises are left unanswered.
Entertaining and pretty cringe but mostly devoid of why. The movie simply states "this happened" which is fine, its a weird enough story to hold attention, but it reaches and fails to grasp any real meaning. The third act attempts to place the experience as motivation for Nasubi later in life but it feels contrived.
Intriguing but incomplete.
Currently streaming on Hulu.
Rent It.
Powell is uncompelling and off-putting as Tyler, unable to hit the charming-asshole balance coming across almost entirely as the latter. Edgar-Jones doesn't make much of an impression either way. They are both conventionally attractive which goes some distance for some but neither is able to really generate any real chemistry nor are they able to make much sense out of their flat, lifeless, improbable characters as-written. With the supporting players though the casting agency out did themselves, it is filled with recognizable up-and-coming talent- Brandon Perea, Sasha Lane, Katy O'Brian, Tunde Adebimpe, Kiernan Shipka, and Nik Dodani- and their presence fills out the mostly lifeless spectacle.
The film has a competent look, the CGI entertaining if not particularly realistic, but the script feels AI generated, the actors executing said script feel like automatons and the plot itself careens from scientific gobbledygook to silly spectacle to incomplete romcom to absolute absurdity. Twister worked because it had serious actors elevating a relatively silly idea. Here the tone is wildly uncertain. For a decades-late sequel Twisters does well as a complete refresh with a young cast unencumbered(for the most part) from clunky tie-ins, although there is a relatively frustrating bait-and-switch non-appearance from Helen Hunt.
The movie has some traction at the box office which I'm all for, whatever gets people in theaters I'm behind, so if you're interested go for it, for me though it was a snoozer.
Currently in theaters.
Stream It.